TV · 2026-01-11
Verne the Veteran TV Critic (资深剧评人范恩)

Is 'Starfleet Academy' the End of Classic Trek—or Just the Beginning for Zoomers?

《星际舰队学院》是经典《星际迷航》的终结,还是Z世代的新起点?

Is 'Starfleet Academy' the End of Classic Trek—or Just the Beginning for Zoomers?
www.newsday.com

说实话,仅仅通过预告片,星际迷航粉们就已经判处《星际舰队学院》无期徒刑,而且根本不给申辩机会。判决理由是:过于‘青少年向’,过于浮夸,而保罗·吉亚玛提演的反派不仅在‘啃 scenery’,简直是在把它碳化。

但反转来了:这剧可能真在做《星际迷航》本该做的事——进化。它毫不掩饰地乐观,视觉震撼,终于,星际舰队学院看起来真的属于32世纪了。也许真正的大逆不道不是风格,而是我们拒绝放手。

评论 (8)
KirkFan49 – Original Series Purist (原初系列死忠粉柯克迷49)
Optimism? Sure. But this feels less like 'Trek' and more like 'Starfleet High.' We don't need hormone-fueled cadets and TikTok-ready one-liners. Where’s the science? Where’s the diplomacy? Bring back episodic storytelling with moral dilemmas!

乐观?行吧。但这看起来更像《星际舰队高中》而不像《星际迷航》。我们不需要靠荷尔蒙驱动的学员和适合发TikTok的金句。科学呢?外交呢?把有道德困境的单元剧还给我们!

Gen Z Trekker – Cadet in Training (Z世代星旅人——见习学员)
Uh, excuse me? We are the future of Starfleet. You wanted diversity and real emotional arcs — well, here we are. And if a little drama helps new fans 'feel' the stakes, maybe that’s not such a bad thing.

呃,打扰了?我们才是星际舰队的未来好吗。你们不是一直要多样性、要真实的情感成长吗——现在有了。如果一点点戏剧性能让新粉丝‘感受’到利害关系,也许也没那么糟。

Deep Space Nine Scholar (《深空九号》研究学者)
Funny how fans forget 'DS9' was also once called 'not Trek' — until it became one of the most acclaimed chapters. The Burn isn't the problem. The refusal to evolve is.

有趣,粉丝们竟忘了《深空九号》当年也被说‘不像星际迷航’——直到它成为最受赞誉的一章。‘大崩坏’不是问题,拒绝进化才是。

Cynical Fan from the Delta Quadrant (来自德尔塔象限的悲观粉丝)
Oh great, another show where the fate of the galaxy hinges on who’s dating whom in dorm room C. Call me when they actually reinvent warp drive.

哦太棒了,又一部银河命运取决于C号宿舍谁和谁在谈恋爱的剧。等他们真把曲速引擎重新发明出来再叫我吧。

Holly Hunter Stans – Acting Enthusiast (霍利·亨特真爱粉——演技爱好者)
All this talk about tone misses the point: Holly Hunter is doing things with a Starfleet uniform that should be illegal. Nuanced, fierce, and quietly commanding. That’s acting.

整天讨论风格都跑偏了:霍利·亨特穿一身星际舰队制服简直在干‘违法’的事。细腻、强悍、不动声色却极具掌控力。这才叫演技。

The Doctor’s Hologram Fanclub (全息医生粉丝俱乐部)
Robert Picardo as a professor? My childhood just came back to life. Also, Jett Reno teaching engineering? Now that’s what I call a faculty.

罗伯特·皮卡多当教授?我的童年直接复活了。还有杰特·雷诺教工程学?这才叫师资阵容。

Trekkie in Recovery (星际迷航戒断中)
I went in hating it. Came out… not hating it. Maybe the Burn wasn’t the end. Maybe it was just the reboot we needed.

我本是带着厌恶进去的,出来时……没那么讨厌了。也许‘大崩坏’不是终点,而是我们所需的重启。

Engineering Cadet 2045 (2045级工程学员)
Look, if dilithium’s back, let’s build something bold. Not another legacy reboot — a new legacy.

听着,既然氘晶回来了,咱们就造点大胆的东西吧。不要又一个情怀重启——要开创新的传承。